Using Lead Acid v Lithium-ion Batteries in UPS Backup Solutions

How do you decide between traditional lead-acid batteries and the latest lithium-ion battery backup solutions when selecting a UPS system for your server room or other critical IT applications?

Whilst lithium-ion battery packs offer longer working lives, lead acid are more cost-effective and to a wider degree more environmentally friendly. Your choice often depends on your budget, availability, and application needs.

What Is an Uninterruptible Power Supply?

Almost everyone knows that UPS systems provide battery backup; however, few are aware of the three major types of UPS systems. The three types of uninterruptible power supply include:

1. Online UPS systems: Provides the most secure form of uninterruptible power when mains power is available and when there is a power outage. The inverter is constantly running and powering the load using either a rectified mains power or generator supply or connected battery set. An automatic transfer switch (relay or static based) monitors the output from the inverter and automatically transfers the load to the raw mains power supply if the inverter output sine wave collapses during an UPS overload, short-circuit or fault condition. The UPS output is ‘no-break’ maintained by the seamless transfer between DC power sources (input rectifier output or battery) and the internal capacitance of the UPS system. Typical sizes range from 500VA to 1MVA, single and three phase UPS, monoblock and modular UPS types. As the UPS inverter is designed for constant running, this type of UPS is commonly used for extended runtimes using plug-in or hardwired external battery extension packs.
2. Line interactive UPS systems: the next step down in uninterruptible power and typical available from 300VA to 3kVA, single phase. The UPS has an automatic voltage regulator (AVR) to which the load is connected and supplied a stabilised and filter AC waveform. The battery is charged by a circuit connected to the input AVR and an inverter is live but not powering the load directly. The inverter ‘switches’ in when the mains power supply fails or fluctuates outside the operating range of the AVR. The switching in time may be from 2-4milliseconds and the inverter output waveform from the inverter may be a sinewave or in lower cost models a square wave (referred to as a pseudo sinewave) or step-wave. Most IT loads can tolerate the break in supply and waveform due to the design of their switch mode power supplies (SMPS) which include their own capacitance (ability to store energy for a short period measured in milliseconds. The components in an IT power supply may be more stressed by the less conditioned output of a line interactive UPS (than an online one) but the real weakness of a line interactive UPS is its lack of an automatic bypass and inability to fail safely to mains if there is a UPS overload or fault condition. Line interactive UPS are more commonly used smaller IT loads and network devices. Some line interactive UPS can have extended backup times using external plug-in battery packs.
3. Standby/Offline UPS systems: offer basic power protection and operate in a similar manner to a line interactive UPS. A filtering circuit provides some protection from electro-magnetic interference (EMI), spikes, transients, and surges. The off-line inverter powers up when there is a power outage in a time of from 2-4ms or more, the output waveform is a pseudo or square-wave and there is no automatic bypass. The battery backup is typically limited to an internal battery and this UPS type is available from 250VA to 1kVA typically.

UPS systems typically use a battery for backup power in case of power outages or unstable mains power. It is ideal to use lead-acid batteries for this type of standby power application, as this type of battery is also used in generator starters, fire alarms, and other standby applications. The primary type of lead acid battery used in a UPS is AGM (absorbent glass mat) but in larger online three phase UPS installations, flooded or wet cells can also be found.

Where does lithium-ion fit in, and what advantages does it have over lead acid AGM and wet cells?

Lithium-ion Backup Batteries

Since 1917, lithium batteries have been developed as rechargeable backup power solutions. Technology has only evolved in the past few decades to produce the type of rechargeable battery we find in mobile phones, tablets, and other products.

The key advantages of lithium-ion batteries over lead acid batteries are their energy density, lack of memory, and fast recharge times.

• Energy Density: is measured in Wh/L (Watt-hours per litre). Lead acid batteries can pack around 50-90Wh/L in a battery set compared to 125-600Wh/L for lithium-ion. Comparing the type of battery technologies can typically show lead acid sets requiring a volume (footprint and height) up to 10 times greater than a comparable lithium-ion backup solution.
• Memory Effect: battery memory can occur when a battery is repeatedly cycled (charged and discharged) before all of its stored energy is released. Memory effect used to be an issue in handheld video records and laptops in the 1980s and 1990s that used NiCad (nickel-cadmium) batteries. It was no unheard of for the battery to collapse quickly due to memory effect and therefore not provide the runtime expected. The only solution being to completely discharge the battery before the next recharge and usage.
• Recharge Times: the recharge of a lead acid battery is a non-linear curve. A rule of thumb is for the battery to recharge to 80% within 24hours, dependent upon the size of the charger used. This would typically be a temperature compensating battery charger than would go into a trickle charge for the last 20% of the recharge which could as long again to achieve 100% charge. Lead acid batteries are therefore ideal for standby applications where there is infrequent usage. The batteries are the partially or fully discharged before recharge. Lithium batteries are far more tolerant of rapid charge/discharge cycles and recharge faster, typically to 80% within 2hours and 100% within 4hours or less. A lithium-ion UPS battery set is also more temperature tolerant than a lead acid battery set which requires a 20-25⁰C ambient. For every 1⁰C rise above 30 their 5-year or 10-year design life halves. Lithium batteries can work up to 40⁰C and have 10–15-year design live expectancy.

Lead acid batteries are exothermic on recharge and give out heat when charging as the cells generate heat from the chemical reaction going on inside them. Thermal runway is unlikely in a lead acid battery and the primary flammable material (the plastic case) can be made from flame retardant materials complying to BS6290 Part 4.

In a lithium-ion battery, the lithium itself is highly flammable when exposed to air (oxygen). Whilst vehicle manufacturers have been quick to embrace lithium batteries to move away from fossil fuel engines, they are very conscious of the potential thermal runaway problem of lithium-ion batteries. A fire can start if the battery is cracked (during a car crash) or has a manufacturing defect leading to an area where heat can build-up leading to thermal runway and potential fire. A fire that due to nature of the combustible material can take days to put out and cool.

More information on battery types:
http://web.mit.edu/evt/summary_battery_specifications.pdf
https://www.cummins.com/news/2019/06/17/spot-difference-lithium-ion-versus-lead-acid-battery-electric-technology

UPS Systems : Lead acid or Lithium Battery Backup?

It is important to note that not all UPS manufacturers offer lithium-ion batteries. Those that do provide limited offers in their UPS ranges. For example, a UPS manufacturer may offer smaller single-phase UPS up to 2-3kVA with lead acid or lithium-ion battery options. These are specific UPS systems designed to work with the respective battery technology and they are not interchangeable. The reason being the unique charging and management characteristics of each type of battery. Prices will also be different with a 20-30% premium being charged for lithium, whether the UPS is an online, line interactive or standby system.

For larger online uninterruptible power supplies, a UPS manufacturer will offer discrete systems or solutions that can be charge either lead acid or lithium batteries. The option is often a firmware setup choice on installation. Again, there will be a price premium for lithium over lead acid. A point to note is that as the size of the UPS in kVA/kW increases so does the size of the UPS battery.

With larger sets this can mean the installation of a sizeable battery within a server room or data centre and if the battery is lead acid, fire suppression should be a key consideration in a risk assessment. If thermal runway were experienced this could lead to fire in the room and the need to evacuate safely and suppress the fire. In addition to a fire suppression system, placing the UPS system and lithium battery set in a separate UPS room that can provide containment of any such and rare issue could help to further reduce the impact of such an event.

UPS Battery Recycling

At their end of useful life, recycling lithium-ion batteries is a major issue. For lead acid batteries there are multiple established recycling centres and companies. Ups to 90% of a lead acid battery can be reclaimed and recycled including the plastic case, lead terminals & plates, and hydrochloric acid. This is not the case for lithium-ion batteries.

With today’s mobile phones, it is almost impossible not to be familiar with the features and benefits provided by lithium-ion battery sets. Older handsets are often sold-on to the second-user market and if a battery requires recycling it is important to place this in the correct waste stream and to consider the battery as general waste.

Lithium battery recycling for electric vehicles (EV) is a problem. So far there is only one dedicated recycling centre in Belgium, Europe. Most of the time EV batteries are repurposed into applications where they can be used for energy storage. Over time the number deployed whether in mobile goods, EVs and UPS systems could lead to a major recycling problem. It is extremely difficult and costly to break down a lithium-ion battery into its components for recycling. Until this problem is solved, and lead acid batteries are on a par for first purchase and recycling, lead acid remains the most sustainable technology.

Summary

Today, lead acid batteries remain the first choice for uninterruptible and backup power systems. They are more cost-effective to purchase, as well as easier to recycle. Lithium battery installations require less floorspace, have faster charge/discharge cycles, & design lives have a 20—30% greater capital outlay.  They are also other installation expenses to consider including environmental monitoring and fire suppression. Lithium therefore has still some way to go before it can dislodge lead acid as the ‘go to’ battery type for UPS installations. Above all the choice depends on how often you expect your UPS battery to discharge. In a typical server room or data centre the UPS battery will either provide short term power as a standby power generator starts up or a longer runtime (using battery extension packs) to either ride through long duration power outages or provide enough time for a controlled shutdown. The fast recharge/charge advantages of lithium only come into play if the site experiences frequent power outages and/or is looking to export excess stored energy to a national grid to benefit from feed-in tariffs. Whilst these may be financially attractive, exporting to an electricity grid could reduce the overall resilience and purpose of the UPS system – to protect critical loads from power outages.

Source:  Server Room Environments